|
The physical characteristics [density, viscosity, surface
tension] of the liquid being sprayed can significantly affect an atomizer's
performance. Unfortunately, the magnitudes of the effects of these characteristics vary with
the atomizer type, design, scale and operating parameters. Even subtle
differences in surface finish, nozzle material and geometry can
significantly affect non-water spray performance.
The
laboratory at spray research is
specifically designed to accommodate the testing of atomizers spraying a
variety of non-water liquids and water-based simulants. We make extensive
use of Designed Experiments to limit the size of the test matrices involving
non-water liquids. It is often possible to use a succession of scaled
instances of large atomizers to predict the full-scale performance with
reasonable accuracy. Extrapolating
from water data to the atomizer's actual performance spraying a specific
liquid is not at all straight-forward. Although the literature is replete
with equations relating some aspect of atomizer performance to liquid
properties, there is little agreement as to the exact details. Additionally,
most of the reported studies have concentrated on the small-scale
pressure-swirl atomizers used in gas turbines, spraying commercial fuels.
For dropsize performance, the general form is: DS
Q
xa
where DS is some characteristic
diameter [e.g.- D32, Dv0.5, D30], and x
is some specific liquid property. For surface tension and the Sauter mean
diameter [D32], the exponent a is cited
variously as 0.19, 0.25 and 1.0. Likewise, for viscosity and D32, the
exponent a is cited as 0.06, 0.118,
0.16, 0.20 and 0.215. Relatively little data as to the relationship between
dropsize performance and liquid density is available. Again however, for D32
the exponent a is cited over a wide
range [i.e.- -0.3767, -0.3215, -0.25, -0.22, 0.125 and 0.5]. The situation is further confounded
by the fact that rarely does a liquid differ from water by a single physical
characteristic. It is clearly unreasonable to expect any single-term
relationship to adequately predict the affect of liquid characteristics on
spray performance based solely on data gathered when spraying water. |